Observatoire d’éthique universitaire
Menu

Council could sell its ‘inappropriate’ biblical paintings

Council could sell its ‘inappropriate’ biblical paintings

Collectif

Tribune des observateurs

Table des matières

Council could sell its ‘inappropriate’ biblical paintings

Read More  The Liberal Democrats have estimated that the sale of the artworks could raise £284,000 from the sale of the suggested trio of “inappropriate” pieces to fund this diversifying project.The proposal has not yet been discussed by the council, which is controlled by Labour, a party which has sought to suggest amendments to the motion, claiming that the Grade II listing of Oxford’s Victorian town hall would make the removal of paintings difficult.It has been suggested that work should nevertheless be undertaken to add “historical contextualisation around these gifts (the artworks), some of which depict themes that are incongruous for a progressive public body”.It is understood that the council already has a working group in place tasked with diversifying options for how to diversify artworks, and has sought advice on how other listed buildings have managed to achieve this.A company may be commissioned to help devise ways to improve diversity in the portraits on display in the town hall, according to council documents.Struggle to make collection diverseResearch by the council has found that there are 115 paintings or other artwork on display, including 45 portraits, with 37 of these depicting men, three depicting women, and two depicting both men and women.The council has previously struggled in its efforts to make this collection more diverse because funding would be needed to source new artworks, and to ensure that they fit with the historical interior of the ornate town hall building.Ms Miles believes her suggestion of selling unwanted artworks would raise sufficient funds to overcome this problem.Discussions about the diversity of public art in Oxford come after the city council created an “Anti-Racism Charter” in 2021, after pledging to tackle discrimination following Black Lives Matter protests the previous year.The charter included commitments to “tackle institutional and structural racism”, to “promote and celebrate the history and achievements of ethnic minorities”, and to ensure “organisations in this city are diverse and representative of the people they serve”.The council has indicated there is no current position on the proposal, as no debate has yet taken place. 

The Liberal Democrats have estimated that the sale of the artworks could raise £284,000 from the sale of the suggested trio of “inappropriate” pieces to fund this diversifying project.

The proposal has not yet been discussed by the council, which is controlled by Labour, a party which has sought to suggest amendments to the motion, claiming that the Grade II listing of Oxford’s Victorian town hall would make the removal of paintings difficult.

It has been suggested that work should nevertheless be undertaken to add “historical contextualisation around these gifts (the artworks), some of which depict themes that are incongruous for a progressive public body”.

It is understood that the council already has a working group in place tasked with diversifying options for how to diversify artworks, and has sought advice on how other listed buildings have managed to achieve this.

A company may be commissioned to help devise ways to improve diversity in the portraits on display in the town hall, according to council documents.

Struggle to make collection diverse

Research by the council has found that there are 115 paintings or other artwork on display, including 45 portraits, with 37 of these depicting men, three depicting women, and two depicting both men and women.

The council has previously struggled in its efforts to make this collection more diverse because funding would be needed to source new artworks, and to ensure that they fit with the historical interior of the ornate town hall building.

Ms Miles believes her suggestion of selling unwanted artworks would raise sufficient funds to overcome this problem.

Discussions about the diversity of public art in Oxford come after the city council created an “Anti-Racism Charter” in 2021, after pledging to tackle discrimination following Black Lives Matter protests the previous year.

The charter included commitments to “tackle institutional and structural racism”, to “promote and celebrate the history and achievements of ethnic minorities”, and to ensure “organisations in this city are diverse and representative of the people they serve”.

The council has indicated there is no current position on the proposal, as no debate has yet taken place.

 

« Ce post est un relevé d’information de notre veille d’information »

Auteur

[side_notes]

Droit de réponse et contributions
Vous souhaitez réagir ? Soumettez une proposition de tribune →

Vous pourriez aimer aussi :

Faut-il en finir avec le constructivisme bourdieusien ?

Cet article propose une critique du constructivisme bourdieusien à l’aune des exigences contemporaines de la recherche scientifique. Il ne conteste ni l’importance historique de Pierre Bourdieu dans la sociologie française ni l’intérêt de certaines de ses enquêtes ; il interroge la portée méthodologique du paradigme constitué autour de l’habitus, du champ, des capitaux et de la domination symbolique. Ce paradigme tend, dans ses usages les plus généraux, à fonctionner comme un récit auto-confirmateur : les faits favorables comme les contre-exemples peuvent être réinterprétés dans la même grammaire de la reproduction et de la domination. Les sciences sociales computationnelles, la psychologie cognitive et les neurosciences ne suppriment pas les variables sociales ; elles imposent cependant de les traiter avec d’autres facteurs, de préciser les mécanismes et de rendre les hypothèses plus vulnérables aux faits. L’article soutient que l’habitus ne constitue pas une cause ultime : il peut être ramené à l’implémentation neurocognitive de régularités d’apprentissage, repérables dans des fréquences statistiques de comportement. Il plaide ainsi pour une sociologie pluraliste, explicative et cumulative, où le constructivisme bourdieusien perd son statut hégémonique.

La leçon de sociologie politique d’Éric Naulleau

Nouveau regard sur le livre d'Eric Naulleau. Un livre puissant. Non seulement pour le plaisir de lecture qu’il procure, son style est tour à tour grave et léger, acide et nostalgique, émouvant et inquiétant, mais encore pour la portée sociale et historique du propos. Par-delà la chronique d’expériences de vie très personnelles, c’est à la compréhension d’un devenir collectif qu’on préfère ignorer
Ce qu'il vous reste à lire
0 %

Peut-être devriez-vous vous abonner ?

Sinon, ce n’est pas grave ! Vous pouvez fermer cette fenêtre et continuer votre lecture.

    S'enregistrer: