Wokism, the facts n°25 - April 2024
Conferences and events
Trouble in heritage? LGBTQIA+ legacies and queer narratives: what role for heritage institutions?
Historically used in English as an insult, the term " queer » (in French “bizarre”, “abnormal”) has been the subject of reappropriation by sexual and gender minorities for several decades, and has gained visibility in the media and academic space in recent years. In the cultural field, this interest has resulted in the multiplication of initiatives (exhibitions, conferences, etc.) inspired by contemporary reflections on sexuality, gender, intersectionality and the storytelling of community cultures. Through this study day, we wish to question the capacity of institutional heritage actors to enrich or promote these reflections, and to integrate these subjects into their professional practices. This day, conceived as a space for sharing, training and exchange, is original in that it poses these questions for all heritage specialties — archaeology, archives, inventory, museums, historical monuments and scientific, technical and natural heritage — and to promote institutional and associative initiatives, both territorial and national and international.
Conference by Khalil Khalsi. Seminar “plastic identities”, Sorbonne University
Many contemporary productions in literature and the human and social sciences reinvest the motif of the dream as a way of life in the so-called Anthropocene era. The renewed interest in animism considers the multilaterality of imaginaries and epistemologies in the context of a global environmental crisis, which would place the West in a community of destiny with so-called non-modern populations. This would then lead Europe, if not to provincialize its knowledge, at least to reinvent it. The dream then appears, by borrowing from alternative cosmologies, as a modality of "reconnection" for which writing offers the laboratory.
“Breasts and biomedicine: between alienations and bodily subversions of gender”
The little-explored articulation between breasts and biomedicine raises fundamental questions about the corporeality linked to this physical attribute. This issue has so far been largely understudied in academic research, particularly in its specific dimension, outside of a more global context involving other parts of the body and bodily practices (Froidevaux-Metterie, 2020). The questions raised by breasts, however, are directly in line with the norms of femininity associated with them, as well as theories of the performativity of gender norms (Butler, 1990). Since the 1960s, various biomedical interventions have emerged, including therapeutic procedures such as mastectomy for medical reasons, as well as reconstructive interventions after oncological treatment. In addition, cosmetic breast surgeries and gender transition surgeries have also become common. This day aims to establish a dialogue between studies in the human and social sciences (HSS) on the social and gendered representation of breasts and medical practices, by examining their role in perpetuating or challenging body stereotypes associated with femininity. In this perspective, we are in line with analyses on the involvement of medicine in the construction of sexed and gendered bodies (Fassin, Memmi and Collectif, 2004; Foucault, 1963, 1976). The works presented highlight the experience of individuals concerned by this specific corporeality, thus highlighting the identity aspect of the female body (Young, 1992; Fortier, 2021).
Gender and heteronormativity in sources: methodological approaches (Saint-Étienne)
Following on from the first two young researchers' seminars organized, the first in 2022 on the theme "Gender and sources. Reading, rereading, misreading" and the second in 2023, entitled "Gender and heteronormativity in sources: representations and transgressions of the heterosexual injunction", this third seminar wishes to focus on the methodological approaches of gender studies through the prism of heteronormativity. The aim is to question the research methods that make it possible to re-evaluate a vision of gender identities and sexualities that is both dualistic and deterministic, directly challenging essentialist conceptions of sexual division.
Decolonizing Thought: Indigenous Perspectives
The coloniality of power remains active on a global level, but how can it be dismantled? The seminar “Decolonizing Thought: Indigenous Perspectives” starts from postcolonial and decolonial theories with a view to constituting a space for the convergence of thoughts and struggles with the radical Other against which Modernity was built: the “Amerindian” (Toledo 2021; Blanco, Delgado 2021). We wish to go further, by inviting representatives of indigenous peoples from various continents to the seminar sessions. Given the exclusion of indigenous peoples from the architecture of power and modern reason, the co-construction of a world with the political vision of indigenous peoples is likely to constitute the radical alternative envisaged (Quijano 2020). The seminar aims to reflect on the construction of its implementation.
GENDER AND CLIMATE: SAME FIGHT?
What are the links between gender and climate? How does climate change create, reveal or accentuate gender inequalities? What can be done to take these issues into account and respond to them effectively, particularly in France?
In this two-part conference, a group of specialists and political leaders will meet to answer these questions (and yours!) in a multidisciplinary, committed and open-to-debate approach.
A year ago now, the Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE) published the report “Gender Inequalities, Climate Crisis and Ecological Transition”. By identifying the gendered injustices of the environmental crisis, this work presents twenty-four recommendations proposing solutions to build a sustainable society that respects gender equality.
The conference will be chaired byHelena Alviar Garcia, Professor at the Sciences Po Law School and moderated by Maxime Forest, political scientist at Sciences Po, specialist in gender policies.
Calls for contributions
Algorithms, artificial intelligence and transformations of work through the prism of feminism
What are the new forms of emotional labor performed by women online? How are feminized professions, particularly those related to care, subject to new forms of rationalization or surveillance? How does the use of algorithms in recruitment processes, or stereotypical representations of female skills in content produced by generative AI tools, reinforce discrimination in the job market? What are the consequences of the under-representation of women and gender and racial minorities in design or decision-making positions within large web companies, but also in training for digital professions?
European Ecofeminisms
For nearly ten years, ILLE researchers have been interested in writing about the Feminine through subjects such as learning to become a woman, crime and its questioning according to gender, origin, and life path. Profound changes in the conception of the world and the environment are disrupting this theme, extending it and making it evolve. The asymmetrical structures of power remain: women whose lives and actions are still, despite social progress, often assimilated to being placed under guardianship or being put out of the picture, are still today in the fight against patriarchy and male domination. But what is the contribution of the ecological perspective in this field? For more than thirty years, numerous international studies have shown a parallel between the treatment of the feminine and ecology, the thought of nature and the feminine experiencing the same fight in ecofeminism.
First used in France by Françoise d'Eaubonne in a book published in 1972, this word, a contraction of "ecology" and "feminism", is based on the principle that women are victims of male domination, and that the relationship to the earth is one of its consequences. The ecological revolution therefore requires a feminist revolution; but how can we thwart the system of male domination over nature and women themselves? D'Eaubonne denounces the sexist organization of society that has allowed the domination of women by men and the destruction of nature through its frenzied exploitation. She sees in the masculine the force of technical destruction of nature and for her, the values of the feminine are the only valid ones for the survival of nature and of human beings. She knows that time is pressing and that, more than revolution, the earth and humanity need mutation. She also advocates a change in relations between the sexes.
Publications
Items
Theses
Racial Digital Injustice: At the Intersection of Surveillance Capitalism and Colonialism
In the era of an unprecedented digital economy, this thesis attempts to understand the relationship between users of the virtual environment and the technology companies in power. In order to understand the consequences of the market, concepts such as digital injustices and racial digital injustices will be studied. Essentially, the objective of this work will be to qualify the place of subaltern classes in the digital ecosystem. A multidisciplinary reflection is required, with particular attention paid to the topo of racism in relation to technology. Consequently, the normative framework regulating the current economic market will be highlighted in order to challenge the ethical issue surrounding the use of technology.
The de-re-constructions of identities of Afro-descendant women in the patriarchal and colonialist order of Medellín, Colombia, in the 21st century: historical, literary and ethnographic journey
This thesis deals with the social and identity situation of women of African descent who live in Medellín, capital of the department of Antioquia, in 21st century Colombia. This research work analyzes the continuities and discontinuities of the identity construction of Afro-descendant women (Afro-antioqueñas, Afro-chocoanas, Afro-costeñas and Afro-Venezuelans, but also heterosexual, homosexual and transsexual), in a patriarchal and colonialist society where symbolic and physical violence, racist and sexist, affect them in an intersectional and multidimensional way. Racialization and sexualization are at the center of our reflection. These are, in fact, the two major oppressions that racialized women have experienced and still experience in the Westernized space, of which Colombia is a part. In their belonging to the African diaspora of the West, the black women of Medellin, are today the heirs of the imbrication of these two oppressions, of this double genealogical misfortune, also of classism, heterosexism and xenophobia, among others, also addressed in this thesis. In a historical, global and Afrodiasporic perspective, we try to understand how sex-gender and "race", as cultural tools of domination, have been elaborated and firmly implanted to hierarchize human beings, confining black women to the lowest rung of the social ladder. From the Colombian context, we have tried to grasp the subalternized place that black women occupy today within the imagined Antioqueño narrative, itself based on whiteness, masculinity and hegemonic femininity, of which paisa women and men, despite their Afro-descendant and native roots, are the most notable representatives in the Colombian imagination. Despite the anchoring of a strong stereotype, Afro-Colombian women, bearers of the ancestral black resistance, continue to carry out important processes of consciousness-raising, decolonization and depatriarchalization individually and collectively. This movement of black female empowerment, crystallized in the figure of Francia Márquez, increasingly questions the founding pillars of the patriarchal, colonialist and capitalist order, which it seeks to transform by asserting itself and establishing a dialogue with other groups in society.
The mutations of LGBT asylum volunteering. From a gay cause to its intersectional reframing
Associative work in support of people in migration situations has developed in a context of intensification of repressive policies against migrants but also activists. Associations that specifically help LGBTI people occupy a particular position in this field, at the crossroads between gay and lesbian movements and the space of the cause of foreigners. This thesis focuses on one of these associations, ARDHIS, based on a long ethnographic survey (2016-2022). It analyzes the transformations of voluntary work that are due to developments within the associative space. It is based on active participant observation, since the researcher's activist involvement has informed her research: this work therefore includes an important reflexive dimension, since the story told is also that of a journey within the association. The first part of the thesis shows how voluntary work has long been defined by a form of identification, based on sexual orientation, between gay volunteers and asylum seekers who were most often male. The truth of the homosexual identity of the latter, justifying asylum, was the key for the former. Sexual orientation, understood as a work skill, then founds the specificity of the association. The second part focuses on the questioning of this model within the association itself, at the cost of significant intergenerational tensions: the rejuvenation of volunteers is accompanied by their feminization. This is when accusations of sexual assault and violence are raised that shake the association. The internal treatment of these accusations comes up against the blindness to the relationship of domination specific to support work, which must then be reframed: the gay cause, defined by sexuality, then becomes a feminist cause, defined in terms of gender. But the lesser identification of the volunteers who determine the new course of the association with asylum seekers also serves as a revelation of what generally remains unthought in activist work in favor of migrants: the racial dimension, since migrants are racialized, unlike activists. In other words, it is now a properly intersectional perspective. This change reflects, not an evolution of immigration policy in France, but social and ideological changes in activist commitment, in the new generations, for sexual minorities in migration.