Observatoire academic ethics
Menu

This section brings together all the analyses classified under this theme.

Featured
Xavier-Laurent Salvador

Hamline's Mohammed

As historian Pierre Vermeren has shown, images of Muslim calendars showing Muhammad circulated freely until the middle of the 20th century in the Maghreb and still today in Shiite countries, proof if any were needed that there is no "single Islamic bloc": science obviously proves Professor de Hamline right. But who cares anymore? While the passions of communities against science are constantly expressed, including within the French University itself, it is important to insist on what brings us together within the same citizenship. At a time when Iranian universities are getting excited to defend the freedom to study at the same time as the worst obscurantists are adorning themselves with the name "Taliban", which in their language, let us not forget, means "students", we are witnessing in the West an unprecedented regression of the universalism of knowledge of which the University should be the temple. 

Read »
The editorials
Vincent Tournier

Do social sciences still have something to say?

A study has just been published in the journal Nature, which has been echoed in the French press. It indicates that, since 1945, scientific discoveries have become less and less revolutionary (or "disruptive"). To reach this conclusion, the authors analyzed the articles published since 1945 by assigning them a "disruptiveness" score. They observed a constant decline in this index. 

Beyond the debates raised by this study, the methodology and conclusions of which are discussed, one is tempted to make a transposition: could it be that the social sciences have followed the same path?

Read »